
Front of 4454 Coldwater Canyon Avenue, Studio City
Quick answer: A fully marketed sale exposes your building to the widest group of buyers and is usually the way to create the most competition. An off-market sale goes to one buyer or a short list, with no public listing. It can be faster and more private, but you give up some competition. Our own sales show both: 2372 S Beverly Glen Blvd drew eleven offers on the market, and 4100 McFarlane Ave drew nine. Off market, 4454 Coldwater Canyon Ave closed in 10 days with an all-cash buyer, and 9312 W Olympic Blvd closed in 30 days with a seller carry-back. The right choice depends on your price goals, timing, privacy needs and how much you already know about who will buy.
How you bring a building to buyers shapes your price, your terms and how fast you close. Every seller makes this choice, whether or not anyone asks them directly: put the building in front of the whole market, or sell it quietly to a buyer who is already lined up. Both paths work, for different reasons. Here is what each one delivers, what it costs you and what our own closings show.
What Each Path Means
- Fully marketed sale. The building gets an offering memorandum, photos, financials and broad distribution to brokers, investors and online platforms. Tours and offers follow on a set schedule.
- Off-market sale. No public listing. The broker brings the building to one buyer or a short list of qualified buyers, often people who have already said what they want.
- Controlled or limited marketing. A middle path: the offering goes only to qualified buyers who sign a confidentiality agreement, which gives some competition without a public listing.

Neither path is right for every building.
Our guide to selling an apartment building in Los Angeles explains where this decision fits in the overall timeline.
What Full Marketing Delivers
The main reason to market a building widely is competition. More buyers usually means more offers, and more offers give you choices on price and on terms.
- 2372 S Beverly Glen Blvd, an 8-unit building near Century City, drew eleven offers. The selected buyer went non-contingent. David Saghian represented both the buyer and the seller.
- 4100 McFarlane Ave in Burbank, a 13-unit building, received nine competitive offers.
- 935 Oxford Ave in Marina del Rey, a single-family sale, drew seven offers and sold $115,000 over the asking price.
More offers also mean better terms. With nine or eleven offers, a seller can choose the buyer with the largest deposit, the fewest contingencies or the most reliable financing, not just the highest number.
The costs of full marketing are time, exposure and effort. Preparing the materials and running tours takes weeks. Tenants and neighbors will know the building is for sale. If the price is set too high, the listing can go stale and buyers start to wonder why it has not sold.

Front of 4100 McFarlane Avenue, Burbank
What an Off-Market Sale Delivers
Off-market sales trade some competition for speed, privacy and certainty. Several of our closings were off market:
- 4454 Coldwater Canyon Ave in Studio City, 15 units, closed in 10 days with an all-cash buyer.
- 9312 W Olympic Blvd in Beverly Hills, 6 units, closed in 30 days with a four-year seller carry-back. David Saghian represented both the buyer and the seller.
- 11927 Kiowa Ave in Brentwood, 9 units, sold off market with an all-cash offer and a 30-day close.
- 20301 Cohasset Ave in Winnetka, 22 units under LA City rent control, sold off market and non-contingent on day one.
- 110 N Orlando Ave in Beverly Grove, 4 units, closed off market in 45 days while the seller completed a 1031 exchange into a Delaware Statutory Trust.
- 845 S Le Doux Rd, a development site next to Beverly Hills, sold off market at $450 per square foot of land, which its closing page describes as a record for residential zoning in the 90035 ZIP code.

Full marketing usually produces the most competition. Off market usually produces the most speed and privacy.
Off market does not have to mean a low price. It does mean you are relying on your broker's knowledge of the buyer pool instead of testing the full market.

Front of 11927 Kiowa Ave, Brentwood
When Each Path Tends to Fit
Full marketing usually fits when:
- You want to find the highest price the market will pay.
- The building is a standard apartment property that many buyers can underwrite.
- You have time to prepare and are comfortable with tenants knowing.
- You are a trustee, executor or partner who needs to show that the property was exposed to the market. See our trustee's guide.
Off market usually fits when:
- A qualified buyer is already identified and the price is supported by closed comps.
- Speed or certainty matters more than squeezing out the last dollar, for example when you are on a 1031 deadline.
- Privacy matters: tenant relations, a family or partnership matter, or a sensitive situation.
- The terms are unusual, such as seller financing, and you want to negotiate them with one buyer.

Ask your broker to show you both paths with closed comps and a net sheet.
How to Protect Your Price in an Off-Market Sale
If you sell off market, ask for the evidence a full campaign would have given you:
- Closed comps. Ask your broker to show recent closed sales that support the price. Our comps guide explains what to look for.
- A net sheet. Compare what you would keep, not just the price. See our net proceeds guide.
- Buyer strength. Proof of funds, a lender letter if financed, and a deposit that becomes non-refundable on a set date.
- Representation. If one broker represents both sides, understand how that works and get it in writing. See can one broker represent both the buyer and the seller?
- An exit. Ask what happens if the buyer falls through, and whether there is a backup.
Compare Offers on Net, Not Just Price
The highest price is only part of the result. Strong terms count too: 1501 N Hollywood Way in Burbank, a 6-unit building, sold at 100% of the asking price to an all-cash, non-contingent buyer and closed in 30 days. Compare offers on price, deposit, contingencies, financing and closing date. Inside the City of Los Angeles, also check whether the price crosses a Measure ULA threshold, which changes what you keep. See our Measure ULA guide.
Timing differs too. A marketed sale adds weeks for preparation and offers. An off-market sale can move straight to escrow. In both cases, escrow itself still takes time for inspections, financing and title.
What Buyers Expect in Each Path
Buyers behave differently depending on how a building reaches them.
- In a marketed sale, buyers expect a full offering package: rent roll, operating statement, photos, disclosures and a clear offer date. Because they know they are competing, they often tighten their terms, for example by shortening due diligence, increasing the deposit or waiving some contingencies, as the non-contingent buyer at 2372 S Beverly Glen Blvd did.
- In an off-market sale, buyers expect to move quickly with less competition. In exchange, the seller can ask for strong terms up front. The buyer at 20301 Cohasset Ave was non-contingent on day one, and the buyer at 4454 Coldwater Canyon Ave paid all cash and closed in 10 days.
Either way, a buyer will still ask for the same core records: leases, rent roll, expenses, permits and any notices. Having them ready helps in both paths. For rent-controlled buildings, see AB 1482 vs. LA rent control (RSO).
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Accepting the first off-market offer without comps. An unsolicited offer can be a good one, but check it against closed sales before you answer.
- Overpricing a marketed listing. A price far above the comps can reduce showings and leave the listing sitting on the market.
- Comparing price only. A slightly lower offer with cash, a short close and no contingencies can be worth more than a higher offer that depends on financing.
- Ignoring tenants. Tenants have rights to notice before entry. Plan showings around them in either path.
- Waiting too long on a 1031 timeline. If you are buying a replacement property, line up your sale path early. See our 1031 exchange page.
The Bottom Line
Neither path is right for every building. Full marketing usually produces the most competition. Off market usually produces the most speed and privacy. Ask your broker to show you both, with closed comps and a net sheet for each, before you decide. To talk through which path fits your building, call David Saghian at (310) 401-1559 or request a free property valuation. You can review all of our sales on the track record page. For typical timelines on either path, see how long it takes to sell an apartment building in Los Angeles.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an off-market apartment sale?
A sale without a public listing. The broker brings the building to one buyer or a short list of qualified buyers instead of marketing it widely.
Do off-market apartment sales sell for less?
Not necessarily, but they test fewer buyers, so you rely on closed comps rather than competition to support the price. A full marketing campaign usually creates more competition. Ask for closed comps and a net sheet before accepting an off-market offer.
Is an off-market sale faster?
Often. It skips preparation and a public offer period. Off-market sales on our closing pages closed in 10, 30, 30 and 45 days.
How many offers can a marketed apartment building get?
It depends on price, location and condition. On our closing pages, 2372 S Beverly Glen Blvd drew eleven offers and 4100 McFarlane Ave drew nine.
Can I keep my sale private from tenants?
An off-market or controlled marketing process limits who knows the building is for sale. Tenants still have their rights, including notice before showings, and the buyer takes the building subject to existing leases.
Should a trustee or executor sell off market?
Fiduciaries often need to show the property was exposed to the market and sold at fair value, which usually favors marketing. Talk with the trust or estate attorney before deciding.
How do I reach David Saghian?
Call (310) 401-1559 or request a free property valuation on lamultifamilyadvisory.com. David Saghian is licensed with Lyon Stahl Investment Real Estate, DRE 01992252.